Epic rep battle: Marketing versus transactional emails

When you have marketing and transactional emails that have conflicting reputations – things can get messy with your domain reputation and ISPs.



Imagine this scenario — you’re a sender that is sending massive amounts of email left and right from the same domain without a care in the world about reputation. I bet you would feel like all that email will help warm your IP, right? Get yourself a good reputation with ISPs?

No. Stop that.

Now we understand that a lot of times, senders might not know that this can cause problems for their reputation and email sending as a whole. This is one of those things that a lot of senders learn with time and sometimes with trial and error.

Your reputation is based on a variety of factors, but the emails you’re sending are a big determining factor. Not all emails serve the same purpose, and that means that they affect your reputation in different ways. Before we get into that, let’s define the emails that affect your reputation the most — Transactional Emails and Marketing Emails.

Transactional email – your service helper

Everybody knows transactional email in some way, shape, or form. Transactional emails are those triggered, one-to-one transactional messages sent to users after they interact with a company, website, or application in some way. They often contain information that the user requested and would want on file, so it’s best to have those emails automated. 

Some examples of different types of transactional emails would be password resets, purchase receipts, welcome emails, confirmation emails, shipping alerts and order confirmations, feedback surveys, ToS updates, and a variety of other notifications.

A lot of people expect to get these emails anyway, and they often want them right after the event is triggered. You don’t want your transactional email running into slow send times or a total lack of notifications at all. Like marketing emails, a lot of transactional emails succeed when best practices are followed.

Marketing emails – your brand megaphone

Marketing emails are one of the best ways to get news about your product and services to new or loyal subscribers in any given email marketing campaign. The cut and dry definition: marketing emails are solicitations sent to email addresses that have opted-in to receive them.

Marketing emails are anything like newsletters, sales promotions, blog updates, third-party offers, promotional invitations — anything that might land in the Promotions tab of your Gmail inbox if you have those tabs enabled.

When done right, email marketing is one of the best ways to retain customers and bring a great ROI for your business. It’s an invaluable part of any marketing strategy, so making sure you’re up to best practices is imperative. Not following best practice can lead to problems with your users, your email service provider (ESP), and ISPs, but which one matters more?

Reputation battle

Marketing and transactional emails are all just emails, but how people perceive them is very different. Some users might not be the biggest fans of marketing emails so sentiment can be shaky from time to time. When marketing emails are performing well, your sending reputation is too. However, if your marketing emails are getting low engagements, your reputation can take a hit.

Transaction-based emails, on the other hand, tend to have very high engagement rates. Why? Transactional emails have information that many users need, so they tend to have higher open rates compared to marketing emails. Like we said earlier, transactional emails are sent when a user makes a request and are a bit more technical, so the nature of the email lends itself to higher engagements.

TL;DR — Transactional emails tend to bring you a higher reputation than marketing emails.

When you have emails that might have a lower reputation paired with emails that lend themselves to higher reputation, things can get messy. If your reputation is taking a particularly bad hit, things like password resets and receipts can end up in the spam folder. Transactional emails in spam lead to unhappy customers, and those make more work for you to solve the problem.

The solution – subdomains

If you find yourself sitting here going, “Oh crap, this is happening to me!” Don’t freak out too much. This problem can be fixed with subdomains. Using subdomains for your marketing and transactional emails allows you to separate those domain reputations. That separation ensures that they don’t affect each other and end up causing problems should something go haywire with either. Great examples of this would be subdomains like marketing.domain.comor for marketing emails and or for transactional emails.

Now there are some finer details to subdomains you should know before separating your marketing and your transactional emails. For one, subdomains are best suited to high volume sending. If you aren’t sending tons of email, it’s best to have just one domain to start with to help start a reputation for your brand.

The same can be said for IPs; if you have massive amounts of emails to send, think about separating your IPs to help control your IP reputation and improve your email deliverability.

Second: don’t use something like (code text:! We see this a lot with senders, and it breaks our hearts because you’re taking out the best engagement – replies! If you have a “do not reply” subdomain setup, create a new one that doesn’t deter customer interaction. If you’re worried about figuring out what to do with all the inbound messages you’ll get, we can help with that.


In an ideal world, all of your emails would have high open and engagement rates across the board. Unfortunately, that is not likely to be the case. By no means should you get rid of either type of email altogether or toss your latest email campaign… you’d be throwing away some of the best customer satisfaction and service tools out there.

However, keeping your marketing and transactional emails separated will help you avoid getting a super sassy complaint on social media about how an email receipt ended up in spam, and your email service provider will thank you.

Related readings

What is transactional email? The basics

Transactional emails are easy to understand, but complex to get right. Mailgun walks you through the basics of transactional emails -

Read more

Designing HTML email templates for transactional emails

Save time and improve your workflow with transactional HTML email templates designed mobile-friendly and tested on all popular email clients. Read more...

Read more

Email blasts: The dos and many don’ts of mass email sending

Email blasts are a great way to get your email messages out to your audiences as fast as possible, unless something goes wrong...

Read more

Popular posts

Mailgun iconSee what you can accomplish with the world's best email delivery platform. It's easy to get started.Let's get sending
CTA icon Mailgun Icon